Karzai and MacKay: Both whistling Dixie

  Niagara Falls, Ontario,
Friday, June 20, 2008
by: Joe Hueglin

Afghan President Karzai and Canada's Defence Minister MacKay both made unrealizable statements this past weekend: Karzai in threatening to retaliate against incursions into Afghanistan across his country's border from Pakistan (1); MacKay by suggesting there was any possibility of a "diplomatic solution to the dispute."(2)

The Afghan National Army is a creation of the United States and other countries, whose presence in Afghanistan maintain Karzai in office. The threat of ANA units without support carrying retaliatory attacks into Pakistan territory is just that, a threat incapable of being effectively acted upon.

MacKay's "diplomatic solution" is even more improbable. While units of the ANA could cross into Pakistan territory, should Karzai be foolish enough to do so, Canada has no possibility of negotiating an end to incursions. The tribal territories have never been effectively under


Pakistan government control. The Pashtuns are one people. They do not recognize the arbitrary Durand line drawn by foreigners in 1893 as dividing them into 25 million Afghans and 15 million Pakistanis. (3)

The current Pakistani government ridden by disputes among its coalition partners and with President Musharraf is unable to act. Rather than sealing off the border it is entering into treaties pacifying those it would have to war with to do so.

Canada would be better served if MacKay's diplomatic skills were employed in seeking to convince the Americans their continuing violation of Pakistan by air attacks was counterproductive. As Eric Margolis writes "Widening the Afghan War into Pakistan is military stupidity on a grand scale, and political madness." (4)

President Karzai's bravado, unfortunately, may be based on his being a shill leading up to just this U.S. action. As for the possibility, let alone probability, of the Government of Canada seeking to rein in the Pentagon and the White House the thought is pure fantasizing.


Joe Hueglin

1. onlinenews, I will send troops to Pakistant to chase militants, says Karzai, June 15, 2008

2. The Chronicle Herald, Pakistan not keeping Taliban out, MacKay says, June 15, 2008


3. Wikipedia, Durand Line


4. Margolis, Eric, A line not to be crossed, American-led war on terror cannot be allowed to spread into Pakistan's Pastun tribal area, June 15, 2008, The Toronto Sun



Retrun to Ensign


This page is a story posted on Ensign which is a daily web site offering a variety of material from scenic images, political commentary, information and news. This publication is the work of Faster Than Light Communications . If you would like to comment on this story or you wish to contact the editor of these sites please send us email.


Editor : Timothy W. Shire
Faster Than Light Communication
Box 1776, Tisdale, Saskatchewan, Canada, S0E 1T0
306 873 2004